Vehicle Dynamics International
  • News
    • Braking
    • Chassis
    • Driveline & Transmission
    • Dynamics Software
    • Electronic Dynamic Control
    • Lightweighting
    • OEM News
    • Ride Comfort
    • Simulation
    • Steering
    • Tires and wheels
    • Vehicle Testing
  • Features
  • Online Magazines
    • December 2024
    • May 2023
    • December 2023
    • May 2023
    • November 2022
    • Spring 2022
    • Subscribe Free!
  • Videos
  • Supplier Spotlight
  • Jobs
    • Browse Jobs
    • Post a Job – It’s FREE!
    • Manage Jobs (Employers)
  • Events
  • VDI Awards
    • 2022 Vehicle Dynamics International Awards: the winners!
    • 2021 Vehicle Dynamics International Awards: the winners!
    • 2020 Vehicle Dynamics International Awards: the winners!
    • 2019 Vehicle Dynamics International Awards: the winners!
    • 2018 Vehicle Dynamics International Awards: the winners!
    • 2017 Vehicle Dynamics International Awards: the winners!
LinkedIn YouTube X (Twitter)
Subscribe to Magazine SUBSCRIBE TO EMAIL NEWSLETTER MEDIA PACK
LinkedIn
Vehicle Dynamics International
  • News
      • Braking
      • Chassis
      • Driveline & Transmission
      • Dynamics Software
      • Electronic Dynamic Control
      • Lightweighting
      • OEM News
      • Ride Comfort
      • Simulation
      • Steering
      • Tires and wheels
      • Vehicle Testing
  • Features
  • Supplier innovations
  • Online Magazines
    1. December 2024
    2. May 2024
    3. December 2023
    4. May 2023
    5. November 2022
    6. Spring 2022
    7. Subscribe Free!
    Featured
    December 10, 2024

    The December 2024 issue of Vehicle Dynamics International is out!

    Braking By Web Team
    Recent

    The December 2024 issue of Vehicle Dynamics International is out!

    December 10, 2024

    The May 2024 issue of Vehicle Dynamics International is out!

    May 20, 2024

    The December 2023 issue of Vehicle Dynamics International is out!

    December 19, 2023
  • Videos
  • Supplier Spotlight
  • Jobs
    • Browse Jobs
    • Post a Job – It’s FREE!
    • Manage Jobs (Employers)
  • Events
  • VDI Awards
    • 2023 Vehicle Dynamics International Awards: the winners!
    • 2022 Vehicle Dynamics International Awards: the winners!
    • 2021 Vehicle Dynamics International Awards: the winners!
    • 2020 Vehicle Dynamics International Awards: the winners!
    • 2019 Vehicle Dynamics International Awards: the winners!
    • 2018 Vehicle Dynamics International Awards: the winners!
    • 2017 Vehicle Dynamics International Awards: the winners!
LinkedIn
Vehicle Dynamics International
Features

Mind the gap

Adam GavineBy Adam GavineAugust 18, 20173 Mins Read
Share LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email

When she considers the widening gap between simulation and physical testing. Amy Stubbs is not thinking about the gap between the results of simulation and test.

“We all know simulation is consistently improving and becoming more reliable and is now a vital tool in vehicle development. The gap that is growing is in the detail. Modern high-performance computing means we are running simulations with more and more detail, and many hundreds of thousands of elements. Yet, the world of test engineering is not keeping up. Test engineers are constantly looking for the minimum possible detail. Can I take another channel out of this setup? Can I test one vehicle once instead of twice?

“Obviously, cost is a huge driver in this, and reducing the number of physical tests performed during a program can have an immediate effect on development costs. Is it a real saving though? When we reduce a physical test to its bare minimum are we missing the opportunity to remove future tests from the program? How often are test engineers repeating whole tests because they didn’t quite get all the detail the first time round?

“The buzz words in many industries are ‘big data’, ‘data mining’ and ‘analytics’; pulling together large amounts of information from many sources and slicing and dicing in numerous ways to extract information and grow understanding. This approach is not taken in the automotive test engineering world, where small data is still the modus operandi.

“My background is in NVH and I constantly see, for example, engineers conducting a test with 40 or 50 channels to understand global modes of a BIW. They then book time on the vehicle again and perform another 10 or 20 channel measurements to understand a problem associated with powertrain mounting and the front subframe. Then another test for road noise on the rear. Then another, and another.

“Modern test acquisition systems don’t always prove cost-prohibitive when using high channel counts, and there are even new tools available that give high levels of test data detail in vastly reduced timescales.

“When an asset is available for test early in a program, shouldn’t we be looking to ensure all tests are done in one sitting? Then, when issues come along later in the build, there isn’t a need to reschedule testing. The information about the front subframe is there ready to be analyzed. This is the approach already taken in other industries, where test assets are such high value that all testing has to be completed in one window of opportunity; second chances are not an option.

“Not only this, if NVH engineers take highly detailed measurements when they have access to a vehicle, this could provide useful information to chassis engineers, and vice versa. If test data is pooled into ‘big data’ from all disciplines, then the sum of the parts becomes more useful to the whole. Back to NVH engineers: we scatter accelerometers over vehicle bodies and powertrains to engineer and develop the vehicle. Yet, at the same time, other teams such as brakes and chassis use accelerometers for tests all potentially taking the same data multiple times.

“Why limit the detail in test data and operate in discipline silos, and, as a result, increase the amount of physical testing that takes place? A ‘big data’ collaborative approach that gives as much information as possible early in a program that can be interrogated when issues occur will ultimately have the cost and time reduction benefits we are all looking for.”

Share. Twitter LinkedIn Facebook Email
Previous ArticleNissan’s BladeGlider in action
Next Article A bucket: the ultimate test for the 2017 Audi A8
Adam Gavine
  • X (Twitter)

Adam divides his time as an editor between the worlds of aviation and motoring. These worlds may seem a little diverse today, but autonomous technology and future urban mobility is bringing them ever-closer. Adam is also chairman of the Vehicle Dynamics International Awards.

Related Posts

Features

McLaren’s strength in carbon fibre technology

March 20, 202510 Mins Read
Features

Recalling the Hillman Imp and its engineer, Tim Fry

March 17, 20255 Mins Read
Features

How artificial intelligence (AI) is influencing vehicle dynamics

March 3, 202511 Mins Read
Latest Posts

Awards for ADAS & Autonomous Vehicle innovation to be announced this week

May 19, 2025

ATTI Awards winners to be announced on 20 May

May 19, 2025

VI-grade launches Cloud platform to boost scalable vehicle simulation capabilities

May 14, 2025
Our Social Channels
  • LinkedIn
Getting in Touch
  • Free Email Newsletters
  • Meet The Editors
  • Contact Us
  • Media Pack
Related Topics
  • Electric & Hybrid Vehicle
  • Industrial Vehicle Technology
FREE NEWS EMAIL!

Get essential industry news from this website direct to your inbox every fortnight


© 2023 Mark Allen Group Ltd | All Rights Reserved
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.